What if I do not want my face in the thumbnail?
Use the thing the viewer came to see: the finished object, an interface crop, a before-and-after pair or a visible problem. Make that subject large enough to recognize. A face is an option, not a requirement for any of these compositions.
Should the thumbnail repeat the video title?
Give each a job. For the review example, “WHAT I KEPT” names the selection while the title supplies the thirty-day context. If both repeat the same sentence, try removing the image text and see whether the package is clearer.
How do I choose between two good designs?
First rule out unsupported promises, unreadable text and awkward crops. Compare the remaining designs at the same small size with their titles. If both are usable, record what each is meant to test; personal preference alone cannot establish which an audience prefers.